Skip to content
Forefront Development Finance
All insights
Credit··5 min read·By Chris Pyne

What actually kills deals at credit committee

Three things sink more development deals at credit than anything else — a feasibility that doesn't reconcile, a builder who can't be verified, and a track record nobody can find.

What actually kills deals at credit committee

Three things kill deals at credit committee more often than anything else. None of them is the deposit. All of them are fixable — if you find them six weeks before the lender does instead of six weeks after.

1. A feasibility that doesn't reconcile

Hard costs sourced from one quote, soft costs from a different year, contingency that's a guess, sales costs missing entirely. A credit analyst can spot an inconsistent feasibility in minutes, and once they do, they stop trusting every other number in it. The fix is dull and decisive: one model, one date, every line sourced, the contingency and sales costs real. Get this right and you've cleared the bar most deals fail at.

2. A builder who can't be verified

A builder who can't supply their last three completed projects with addresses, or who's offering cost-plus on a deal the lender expects to be fixed-price, is a problem the credit memo can't wave away. The lender is underwriting your builder almost as hard as they're underwriting you. If there's a related-party head contract — common for builder-developers — that narrows the lender shortlist, but it doesn't kill the deal, as long as the structure and controls are presented clearly.

3. A track record nobody can find

A developer who's been "in development for fifteen years" but can't produce a profit-on-cost track record — because everything was funded inside related-party structures and the receipts are scattered — gives the lender nothing to lean on. Experience you can't evidence is, to a credit team, experience that didn't happen. Pulling that history together before you apply is worth more than another half-percent of equity.

The pattern across all three: credit committees decline on doubt, not on numbers. The work that gets a deal funded is the work that removes the doubt before the question is asked.

About the author

Chris Pyne arranges development finance for Australian property developers through Forefront Development Finance — the development-finance operating brand of Forefront, a Gold Coast commercial finance brokerage. 15+ years in commercial lending, $100M+ settled across construction, residual stock and bridging facilities.

Forefront Development Finance — Credit Representative 478424 of Connective Credit Services Pty Ltd, ACL 389328. Information on this site is general in nature and does not constitute financial, legal, tax or credit advice. Lending is subject to lender approval, terms, conditions, fees and charges. Always seek advice tailored to your circumstances.

Got a deal in mind?

Twenty minutes. We'll tell you if it's fundable.

If your deal is fundable, you will know inside the call. If it is not, you will know why — and what to fix before it is. Either way, twenty minutes well spent.